The Great Marketing Dilemma: Should You Hire In-House or Partner with an Agency?

Picture This…

You’re at a crossroads in your business journey. Your marketing needs are growing, and you’re faced with a crucial decision that could shape your company’s future. Should you hire an in-house marketing expert or partner with an agency like Marketer on the Run?

Let’s break this down with a story of two business owners:

Meet Sarah and Mike

Sarah and Mike both run successful SaaS startups, but they took different paths with their marketing strategies. Sarah went the in-house route, while Mike chose to partner with an agency. Their experiences reveal some interesting insights…

The In-House Route (Sarah’s Story):

• Complete brand immersion (her marketer lives and breathes the company culture)

• Direct control over priorities and timelines

• Real-time communication and quick pivots

• But… she faced challenges with:

  • Limited skill diversity (one person can’t master everything)
  • Higher long-term costs (salary, benefits, training)
  • Productivity gaps during vacation or sick days

The Agency Partnership (Mike’s Story):

• Access to diverse expertise and specialized tools

• Flexible scaling of services

• Fresh, outside perspective on strategies

• His challenges included:

  • Initial adjustment period
  • Sharing attention with other clients
  • Less direct control over day-to-day execution

The Solution? Think Hybrid

Here’s where it gets interesting – the most successful businesses often find a sweet spot between these options. Consider this approach:

  1. Start with your core needs:
    • What’s your monthly marketing budget?
    • Do you need specialized expertise or general marketing support?
    • How much direct control do you want over daily operations?
  2. Consider your growth stage:
    • Early-stage: An agency can provide comprehensive support without the overhead
    • Growth phase: Mix agency expertise with in-house coordination
    • Enterprise level: Blend in-house team with agency specialists
  3. Evaluate your resources:
    • Time available for management
    • Budget flexibility
    • Internal expertise gaps

The Actionable Takeaway

For businesses spending $500-$1500 monthly on marketing, starting with an agency partnership often provides the best value.

Why? You get:

• Diverse expertise without the full-time salary commitment

• Scalable services that grow with your business

• Professional guidance in strategy development

• Access to premium tools and resources

Remember: The goal isn’t just to fill a marketing position – it’s to create a sustainable growth engine for your business.

If you’re ready to start a conversation about whether or not we’re the right team to help you on your business journey, contact us today and let’s assess whether our agency can suit your goals.