The Great Marketing Dilemma: Should You Hire In-House or Partner with an Agency?

Image

Picture This…

You’re at a crossroads in your business journey. Your marketing needs are growing, and you’re faced with a crucial decision that could shape your company’s future. Should you hire an in-house marketing expert or partner with an agency like Marketer on the Run?

Let’s break this down with a story of two business owners:

Meet Sarah and Mike

Sarah and Mike both run successful SaaS startups, but they took different paths with their marketing strategies. Sarah went the in-house route, while Mike chose to partner with an agency. Their experiences reveal some interesting insights…

The In-House Route (Sarah’s Story):

• Complete brand immersion (her marketer lives and breathes the company culture)

• Direct control over priorities and timelines

• Real-time communication and quick pivots

• But… she faced challenges with:

  • Limited skill diversity (one person can’t master everything)
  • Higher long-term costs (salary, benefits, training)
  • Productivity gaps during vacation or sick days

The Agency Partnership (Mike’s Story):

• Access to diverse expertise and specialized tools

• Flexible scaling of services

• Fresh, outside perspective on strategies

• His challenges included:

  • Initial adjustment period
  • Sharing attention with other clients
  • Less direct control over day-to-day execution

The Solution? Think Hybrid

Here’s where it gets interesting – the most successful businesses often find a sweet spot between these options. Consider this approach:

  1. Start with your core needs:
    • What’s your monthly marketing budget?
    • Do you need specialized expertise or general marketing support?
    • How much direct control do you want over daily operations?
  2. Consider your growth stage:
    • Early-stage: An agency can provide comprehensive support without the overhead
    • Growth phase: Mix agency expertise with in-house coordination
    • Enterprise level: Blend in-house team with agency specialists
  3. Evaluate your resources:
    • Time available for management
    • Budget flexibility
    • Internal expertise gaps

The Actionable Takeaway

For businesses spending $500-$1500 monthly on marketing, starting with an agency partnership often provides the best value.

Why? You get:

• Diverse expertise without the full-time salary commitment

• Scalable services that grow with your business

• Professional guidance in strategy development

• Access to premium tools and resources

Remember: The goal isn’t just to fill a marketing position – it’s to create a sustainable growth engine for your business.

If you’re ready to start a conversation about whether or not we’re the right team to help you on your business journey, contact us today and let’s assess whether our agency can suit your goals.

Get the newsletter